Short answer
Contemporaneous documentation under section 247: a functional analysis, the transactions and their terms, the method chosen and why it's most appropriate, and the comparables supporting the price — complete by the filing due date, produced within 3 months of a CRA request.
What “contemporaneous” actually demands
Section 247's penalty protection depends on records made or obtained by the filing-due date for the year, describing: the property or services transacted and the participants; the terms and their relationships; the functions performed, assets used and risks assumed by each party; the transfer pricing method selected and the rejection of alternatives; and the comparable transactions or benchmarks relied on.
When the CRA issues a written request, you have three months to produce the package. Documentation assembled after the request does not count as contemporaneous — the penalty shield is gone before the audit begins.
The penalty math
Where adjustments exceed the lesser of $5 million and 10% of gross revenue, a 10% penalty applies to the adjustment — unless reasonable efforts to determine arm's-length prices are documented. The penalty is about the paperwork, not the price: a defensible price with no documentation is still exposed.
Larger groups add the BEPS layer: a master file and local file aligned to OECD Action 13, and country-by-country reporting once consolidated group revenue passes €750 million.
Right-sizing the exercise
A two-entity group recharging management services does not need a hundred-page study — it needs the intercompany agreement, a clean functional analysis, a method note and a benchmark that fits. We scale documentation to transaction risk: routine low-value services on the simplified approach, distribution margins benchmarked properly, and anything touching IP or financing treated as the audit magnet it is.
Reviewed for the 2025 tax year by Udit Gupta, Cross-Border Tax Expert, Legal Quotient Consultants.
General information, not advice for your specific situation —
contact us on the 24-hour helpline to discuss your circumstances.