What makes technology & saas different from an ordinary filing?
Software and subscription revenue is characterised differently across jurisdictions — as services, as royalties, or as a digital supply — and the characterisation changes both withholding and indirect tax. An ordinary preparer applies the general rule and stops there, which is how the relief in the specific provision goes unclaimed.
Can you work with my existing accountant?
That is how most of these engagements run. They keep the domestic file, we take the cross-border piece, and the boundary is agreed in writing so nothing is done twice or missed.
Why do some customers withhold tax on our software invoices?
Because their country characterises what you sell as a royalty and theirs is a jurisdiction that taxes royalties at source. A customer paying for the right to use software, or for anything their local law treats as the use of copyright, is often obliged to deduct tax from the invoice and remit it. Another customer, in a country that treats the same subscription as a service, deducts nothing. The invoice looks identical from your side, which is why the pattern appears arbitrary. It is not about the customer's willingness to pay; it is about how each country classifies the payment.
Is SaaS revenue a royalty or a service under the treaty?
It varies by treaty and by country, and the distinction usually turns on what the customer actually receives. A right to use copyright, to reproduce software or to exploit it commercially points towards a royalty. Access to hosted functionality, with no copy delivered and no right to modify or redistribute, points towards a service or a digital supply. Some countries take a broader view of royalty than others and will characterise ordinary subscription access that way. The answer is reached contract by contract and country by country, reading the licence terms you actually grant rather than the description on your price list.
Do engineers in another country create a taxable presence for us?
They can. A team carrying on the company's business from a place in another country, whether an office or their own homes, can constitute a presence through which business is conducted, and the question is whether their activity is core to the business rather than supporting. Product development usually is core. The consequence is a corporate filing obligation in that country and an exercise attributing profit to the activity performed there. Employment and payroll obligations arise separately and generally earlier. Hiring the first engineer in a new country is a structural decision, not just a recruitment one.
Can we reclaim tax a customer withheld from our invoice?
There are two routes and they are not the same. Where the treaty reduces or removes withholding on that type of payment, the customer should apply the reduced rate at source once you provide residence certification, and the excess already deducted may be reclaimable from the customer's tax authority under its own procedure and time limit. Separately, tax properly withheld may be creditable against your own corporate tax at home, provided you have the withholding certificate and the income is taxable there in the same period. A credit is worth nothing in a loss year, which is where many software businesses sit.
Should our contracts state who bears any withholding tax?
Yes, and the absence of that clause is the most common commercial gap we see. Without it, the customer deducts, you receive less than the contract price and the argument happens after the money has gone. A gross-up clause obliges the customer to pay the amount that leaves you whole, but it prices the risk into the deal and some customers will not accept it. The alternative is to price with the withholding assumed and to require the withholding certificate, so that at least the credit is available. Decide which before signing, by country, rather than discovering it on the first remittance.
Do we charge indirect tax on subscriptions sold to overseas consumers?
Usually yes, where the consumer is. Digital supply regimes generally place the tax where the customer belongs and require a non-established supplier to register and charge once it sells to consumers there, often from the first sale or from a low threshold. Sales to business customers are frequently handled differently, with the obligation shifted to the buyer, so the split between consumer and business revenue directly determines where you must register. That makes customer status evidence, and the validation of any business registration number a customer supplies, part of the tax function rather than a sales formality.
How does the treaty tie-breaker work when both countries say I am resident?
As a sequence, stopping at the first test that gives an answer: where you have a permanent home available; if in both or neither, where your centre of vital interests is; then habitual abode; then nationality; and if all of those tie, the two tax authorities decide by agreement. It is evidential rather than elective — you do not choose your treaty residence, you demonstrate it, which makes the record of homes, family and time the substance of the claim. See tie-breaking dual residency.
Is "fund transfer pricing" the same thing as transfer pricing?
No — and if you came here to calculate FTP, this is not it. Fund transfer pricing is a bank's internal allocation of funding costs and benefits between its own business units, a treasury and asset-liability management discipline used to measure branch or product profitability. Tax transfer pricing is about prices between legally separate related parties across borders, and about which country taxes the resulting profit. The words overlap; the fields do not. See our transfer pricing work.